48Received 09.08.2021. Revised 28.04.2022. Accepted 30.05.2022.
Abstract. Essay aims at a critical appraisal of the prominent contemporary French social thinker Emmanuel Todd’s writings that explore constituent features of different family types and their psychological “worlds”. By delineating economic, educational and family relations as belonging respectively to conscious, subconscious and nonconscious spheres he asserts that different family types produce distinctive sets of values that account for person’s nonconscious preference for liberty versus authority, inequality versus equality etc. According to Todd to each type of family corresponds a particular ideology, political regime, religion etc. Thereby French sociologist provides original and rather unexpected insights into many social phenomena namely predisposition to liberalism, social democracy, communism, racism, xenophobia etc. Of a particular value is his elucidation of the anthropological roots of individualistic (American-type or absolute nuclear family) and coordinated (German and Japanese or stem family) capitalisms that sheds a new light on supposedly rather well documented story of the varieties of capitalism. However, in economic matters Todd is not always at his best. By describing homo economicus as a conscious but always acting in a framework of particular nonconscious family values, he somewhat blurs distinction between of conscious and nonconscious. In fact, he seems to have never been precise as to which – individual (personal) or collective (societal) – nonconscious family values modify person’s economic performance. As he sharply criticizes Germany for imposing a stem family (austerity) type economic policy on EC, one may deduce that they interact at least at a national level. French thinker’s theory critically depends on the thesis of an exceptional longevity of nonconscious family values, seemingly a rather questionable idea however supported by evidence. Even accelerating atomization of societies making family values’ influence more subtle does not undermine the validity of this his central thesis. Todd’ works are not without flaws but they are highly provocative, original and pathbreaking.
Keywords: anthropology, family type, beliefs, culture, liberalism, authoritarianism, equality, ideology, religion, varieties of capitalism, homo economicus
REFERENCES
1. Beuve-Méry A. Quand Emmanuel Todd tente “d’expliquer l’inexplicable”. Le Monde, 07.02.2020. Available at: https://www.lemonde.fr/idees/article/2020/02/07/quand-emmanuel-todd-tente-d-expliquer-l-inexplicable_6028721_3232.html (accessed 31.05.2022).
2. Dedieu F., Petit P. Entretien avec E. Todd. Les Différences de Classe Vont l’Empoter sur Celles de Sexe, d’Âge ou de “Race”. Marianne Magazine, 18–24.09.2020, no. 1227, pp. 52-56.
3. Larregue J. Who is Emmanuel Todd? American Sociologist, 2017, vol. 48, no. 3-4, pp. 476-477. DOI: 10.1007/s12108-017-9349-x
4. Todd E. La Troisième Planète. Structures Familiales et Systèmes Idéologiques. Paris, Éditions du Seuls, 1983. 251 p.
5. Le Ple P. Basic Constitution of the Human Race: Ideas, Morals and Institutions of Prosperous Peoples. Moscow, Knizhnyi dom “LIBROKOM”, 2012. 235 p. (In Russ.)
6. Le Play M.F. Ouvrières Européens. Études sur les Travaux, la Vie Domestique et la Conditions Morale des Populations Ouvrières de l’Europe. Paris, 1845. 301 p.
7. Todd E. Oú en Sommes Nous? L’une Esquisse de l’Histoire Humaine. Paris, Éditions du Seuls, 2017. 496 p.
8. Todd E. Where We Are Going: History through the Eyes of an Anthropologist. Moscow, Eksmo, 2021. 512 p. (In Russ.)
9. Todd E. L’Enfance du Monde: Structures Familiales et Développement. Paris, Éditions du Seuls, 1984. 251 p.
10. Todd E. L’Origine des Systèmes Familiaux. Tome I. Eurasie. Paris, Gallimard, 2011. 755 p.
11. Todd E. L’Illusion Économique. Essais sur la Stagnation des Sociétés Développées. Paris, Éditions du Seuls, 2003. 392 p.
12. Mamadouh V. A Political-Cultural Map of Europe. Family Structures and the Origins of Differences between National Political Cultures in the European Union. GeoJournal, 1999, vol. 47, no. 3, pp. 477-486. Available at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/41147324
13. Duranton G., Rodriguez-Pose A., Sandall R. Family Types and the Persistence of Regional Disparities in Europe. Economic Geography, 2009, vol. 85, no. 1, pp. 23-47. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1944-8287.2008.01002.x
14. Todd E. L’Invention de l’Europe. Paris, Éditions du Seuils, 1990. 542 p.
15. Leick R. Gesprӓch mit E. Todd. “Europa ist Futsch”. Spiegel, 04.08.2018, Nr. 32, S. 112-116.
16. Le Bras H., Todd E. Le Mystère Francais. Points. Essais. Paris, La République des Idées. Éditions du Seuls, 2015. 321 p.
17. Todd E. La Nouvelle France. Paris, Éditions du Seuls, 1988. 283 p.
18. Mylonas K., Gari A., Giotsa A., Pavlopoulos V., Panagiotopoulou P. Greece. Georgas J., Berry J. W., van de Vijver F., Kağitcibaşi C., Poortinga Y.H., eds. Families Across Cultures. A 30-Nation Psychological Study. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2006, pp. 344-352.
19. Todd E. Qui est Charlie? Sociologie d’une Crise Religiouse. Paris, Éditions du Seuls, 2015. 242 p.
20. Todd E. Explanation of Ideology: Family Structures and Social Systems. Oxford–New York, Basil Blackwell, 1985. 230 p.
21. Courbage Y., Todd E. A Convergence of Civilizations: The Transformation of Muslim Societies around the World. New York, Columbia University Press, 2011. 134 p.
22. Hall P. A., Soskice D., eds. Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantages. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2001. 540 p.
23. Volferen K. Mystery of Japanese Power. People and Politics in a State without a State. Moscow, Serebryanye niti, 2020. 568 p. (In Russ.)
24. Buyzh M. Family Values that Would Change the World. Ekspert, 24.12.2018–20.01.2019, no. 1–3 (1103), pp. 72-77. (In Russ.)
25. Todd E. Lineages of Modernity: A History of Humanity from the Stone Age to Homo Americanus. Cambridge; Medford (MA), Polity, 2019. 370 p.
26. Lemonnier M. Le Retour de la Lutte des Classes. Entretien avec Emmanuel Todd. L’OBS, 23.01.2020, no. 2881, pp. 65-69.
27. Todd E. Les luttes de classes en France au XXIe siècle. Paris, Éditions du Seuls, 2020. 384 p.
28. Todd E. Traurige Moderne: Eine Geschichte der Menschheit von der Steinzeit bis zum Homo Americanus. Munchen, C. H. Beck, 2018. 537 S.
29. Todd E. Breve Storia dell’Umanità: Dall’Homo Sapiens all’Homo Oeconomicus. Gorizia, LEG, 2019. 421 p.
Registered in System SCIENCE INDEX
No comments