Westphalian Myth: History and Criticism
Publication Type:


ISSN 2713-170X

DOI: 10.20542/afij-2019-3-37-50

The article is devoted to the deconstruction of the so-called Westphalian Myth, a set of ideas about the Peace of Westphalia as the starting point and basis of the modern world order. The article is largely historiographic in nature and is intended to summarize for the Russian reader the position of critics of the Westphalian Myth. According to the author, the genesis of the Westphalian Myth dates back to the works of Leo Gross and Hans Morgenthau, who created a concept that formed the basis of the generally accepted history of international relations within the framework of the discipline of IR. Until recently this concept did not raise questions among researchers. However, the 1990s saw a so-called ‘Historical Turn’ in IRs, when historians and specialists in international law and IR challenged the generally accepted concept, after analyzing the text of the treaties of the Peace of Westphalia. The author identifies two waves of ‘Historical Turn’. The first criticized the Westphalian Myth for its inconsistency with historical facts, the second focuses on the criticism of the Westphalian Myth as a Eurocentric construct that does not take into account the events taking place in the rest of the world at that time. Further, the author examines one of the key provisions of the Westphalian myth: the idea of the Thirty Years War as an existential conflict, during which the Spanish and Austrian Habsburgs tried to destroy the nation states in Europe and establish a universal monarchy. Analyzing the course of hostilities, the author comes to the conclusion that during most of the Thirty Years War, the Austrian Habsburgs defended themselves and were engaged in suppressing rebellions on their territory and repelling the invasions of foreign troops. The coordination of the Spanish and Austrian Habsburgs was rather weak, each branch of the dynasty pursued primarily its own interests. Further, the author considers two more claims of the Westphalian Myth: that the Westphalia established a balance of power in Europe, and that the religious factor in the post-Westphalian period was reduced. The author demonstrates that the Peace of Westphalia and Peace of Pyrenees did not mark a transition to a balance of power in Europe, but the growth of French hegemony, which was stopped only after series of wars resulted in signing of the Peace of Utrecht. In addition, the author argues that the religious factor played an important role in European politics until the 19th century. 


Keywords: Peace of Westphalia | Thirty Years War | History of International Relations | Westphalian Myth | France | Holy Roman Empire |

Russian Science Citation Index



OTHER PUBLICATIONS ON THIS TOPIC

Соболевская А.А.
Имперские традиции России и евразийство. /А.А. Соболевская, А.К. Попов // Философия хозяйства. – 2014. – № 3. – С. 109 – 124

Kupriyanov Alexey
История МО: попытка описания [Текст] / А. В. Куприянов // Россия в глобальной политике. – 2019. – Т. 17. – № 2. – С. 202-210. – Рец. на кн.: Фененко А. В. История международных отношений: 1648–1945: Учеб. пособие. – М., Аспект-Пресс, 2018.

Ostrovskaya Helena
Франция в эпоху перемен / Е.П. Островская // Современная Европа. – 2012. – № 1. – С. 154–157. – Рец. на кн.: Франция. Время Саркози / Ю.И. Рубинский – М.:, Международные отношения, 2011. – 320 с.

History of the International Relations. Ed. by Kamenskaya G.V., Kolobov O.A., Solovyev E.G. Moscow, Logos Publishers, 2007.

Arbatov Alexey
До основания, а затем…. [Текст] / А.Г. Арбатов // Россия в глобальной политике. – 2017. – № 3. – С. 84-103.

Cherkasov Petr
Интеллектуальный путеводитель по исторической и современной Франции [Текст] / П.П. Черкасов // Новая и новейшая история. – 2017. – № 6. – С. 118-122.

Trofimova Olga
Франция: глобализация, интеграция, сохранение национальных интересов / О.Е. Трофимова // Современная Европа. – 2008. – № 4. – С. 87–99.

Mukhanov Vadim
The Burning Issues of the Common Russian-Georgian History in Contemporary Socio-Political Discourse

Voronov Konstantin
Швеция в двух мировых (Второй и холодной) войнах: другая история // Международная жизнь. 2020. № 9. С. 72-83.

Международные организации: история и основные тенденции развития. Соловьев Э.Г. и др. Н.Новгород, 2002.

Vasil'ev Victor
World War II in Public Opinion of Modern Germany / Vasilyev V.I.

System History of International Relations. 1918-2003 Events and Documents. In four volumes. Vol. 3, 1945-2003. Ed. by Bogaturov A.D. Moscow, Research and Educational Forum on International Relations, 2003.

Baranovsky Vladimir
Basic Parameters of Modern System of International Relations. Part III. // Polis Journal.Political Studies, 2012, № 5. P. 148–158.

Baranovsky Vladimir
Basic Parameters of Modern System of International Relations. Part II. Qualitative Parameters // Polis Journal.Political Studies, 2012, № 4. P. 63–73.

Baranovsky Vladimir
Basic Parameters of Modern System of International Relations (Part I) // Polis Journal.Political Studies, 2012, № 3. P. 36–44.

Lukonin Sergey
Торговая война Китай-США: Осакский раунд [Текст] / С. А. Луконин // Russia Policy Review [на корейском языке]. – 2019. – Т. 3. – № 3. – С. 24-27.

Cherkasov Petr
Russophobia: Reality or Myth? Through the Pages of the Book of Guy Mettan

Gadzhiev Kamaludin, Kamensakya Galina, Solovyev Eduard
Очерки истории международных отношений. Нижний Новгород, 2001, 35 п.л.

Karimova Alla
Социология международных отношений в парадигмах поведения и деятельности [Текст] / А. Б. Каримова // Наука. Культура. Общество. – 2018. – № 2-3. – С. 40-56.

Kudryavtsev Andrey
Франция: уравнение со многими неизвестными [Текст] / А. К. Кудрявцев // Бизнес и выставки. – 2019. – № 1 (97). – С. 26-29.
Related publications


Comments (0)

No comments

Add comment







First news
Institute News
10/06/2022

The next issue of the journal ME & MO (No. 6, 2022), which opens with a panoramic article by V. Mikheev and S. Lukonin, has been published. The authors dedicated it to China on the eve of the 20th CPC Congress. In the economic block of the magazine special attention is paid to digital currencies.

more...

09/06/2022

An article by Marina Klinova «The State and Energy Security in the World and Europe as a Public Good» was published in the June issue of the journal «Voprosy Ekonomiki» ("Economic Issues") under the heading "International Economics" (in Russian).

more...

Recently Published