A Rejoinder to a Contemporary Non-Economist A Comment on a Comment
ISSN 1726-3247
DOI 10.17323/1726-3247-2019-3-185-205
The article is a rejoinder to a critical assessment of Kapeliushnikov’s study on discursive methods used by M. Weber in The Protestant Ethics and the Spirit of Capitalism that was provided by Ivan Zabaev in his recently published article, “A Nietzschean Take on a Hundred-Dollar Bill: Reading Weber’s ‘Protestant Ethic’: in Connection with a Contemporary Economist’s Comments.” Kapeliushnikov demonstrates that Zabaev’s attempt to view The Protestant Ethics and the Spirit of Capitalism as a treatise on ethics rather than as a scientific study is not justified, and that Weber himself would hardly approve such a moralistic approach. The tendency to substitute a substantive discussion for a manipulation with words is also without merit. For instance, Zabaev’s suggestion that for Weber the German words Gewinn and Erwerb had a diametrically opposite sense is quite absurd. Kapeliushnikov’s commentary pays special attention to Zabaev’s attempts to interpret Weber’s study through a lens of Nietzschean ideas. Paradoxically, this approach has led Zabaev to unequivocally anti-Weberian conclusions. In particular, this Nietzschean interpretation of a famous metaphor of “a steel shell” gets a meaning that is completely at variance with its original conception. Kapeliushnikov concludes that a traditional approach when The Protestant Ethics and the Spirit of Capitalism is seen as a study on economic history or historical sociology rather than as a treatise on ethics is more correct and does not engender numerous aberrations that Zabaev was not capable of avoiding.
Keywords: Weber | «The Protestant Ethics and the Spirit of Capitalism» | science | ethics | calling | economic history | B. Franklin | F. Nietzsche |
Russian Science Citation Index
OTHER PUBLICATIONS ON THIS TOPIC
Studentsov Victor
Rereading Max Weber’s "Protestant Ethic": Questions, Doubts, and Objections
Kapelyushnikov Rostislav
Weber's Hypnosis Notes on «The Protestant Ethics and the Spirit of Capitalism
Kapelyushnikov Rostislav
Weber's Hypnosis. Notes on “The Protestant Ethics and the Spirit of Capitalism”
Gasratyan K.
Ethics of Human Activity and Welfare Economy / Gasratyan K.M.
Gasratyan K.
Этика и homo oeconomicus [Текст] / К.М. Гасратян // Журнал экономической теории. – 2016. – № 1. – С. 105 – 114.
Studentsov Victor
Puritans’ Economy: Solidarity Versus Profit-Seeking
Gadzhiev Kamaludin
Политология: учебник для вузов. – 6-е изд., перераб. и доп. – Москва: Издательство Юрайт, 2021. – 493 с. – 1000 экз. – ISBN 978-5-534-14338-6.
Avtonomov Vladimir , Belyanin A.
Behavioural Institutes of Marker Economy / Avtonomov V., Belyanin A.
Shlikhter Alexey
Идейные основы и практики социально-ориентированной деятельности корпораций и благотворительных фондов на Западе и в России [Текст] / А.А. Шлихтер // Общество и экономика. – 2017. – № 12. – С. 76-90.
Kudrov Valentin
The evolution of modern capitalism. Russia should participate in the global process of evolution.
Bardin Andrey, Stomin V.
Artificial intelligence in urban governance: barriers and prospects for implementation
Avtonomov Vladimir
Методология "Основ политической экономии" М.И. Туган-Барановского в сопоставлении "Принципов" А. Маршалла [Текст] / В. С. Автономов // Вопросы теоретической экономики. – 2019. – № 1. – С. 24-29. DOI: 10.24411/2587-7666-2019-10102.
Kondrat’ev Vladimir
Перспективы финансового капитализма // Перспективы. Электронный журнал. 2021. № 2-3 (25-26). С. 160-177. DOI 10.32726/2411-3417-2021-2-3-160-177. URL: http://www.perspektivy.info/upload/iblock/51b/2_3_2021_0_160_177.pdf (дата обращения 28.12.2021).
Studentsov Victor
Воспитание для капитализма? Кальвинизм и церквно-государственная дисциплина в XVI веке [Текст] / В. Б. Студенцов // Новая и новейшая история. – 2019. – № 1. – С. 37-47. DOI: 10.31857/S013038640003803-1.
Gadzhiev Kamaludin
Политология. Базовый курс: учебник для бакалавров. 3-е изд., перераб. и доп. М., Издательство Юрайт, 2012, 463 с.
Kapelyushnikov Rostislav
Is economic inequality a universal evil?
Portansky Alexey
Return of Keynes
Sheinis Viktor
Rissian history according to Gavriil Popov / Sheunis V.L.
Portansky Alexey
Возвращение Кейнса [Текст] / А.П. Портанский // Деньги и кредит. – 2017. – № 3. – С. 61 – 65. - Рец. на кн.: А. Остальский. Спаситель капитализма. Джон Мейнард Кейнс и его крест. – М.: Пальмира, 2017, 384 с.
Zolotareva V., Yemelyanova Olesya
Models of "Catch-Up Modernisation" in the Countries of "Peripheral Capitalism": the General and the Particular
Related publications
No comments