Naumkin Vitaly
Non-West Model: Does the Civilization-State Exist?
Publication Type:

ISSN 1026-9487

DOI 10.17976/jpps/2020.04.06

The article reviews some aspects of civilizationism as a trend in self-positioning strategies as adopted by several Asian states, primarily by China and India, as well as some other nations. Close attention is paid to the concept of the civilization-state (CS), as distinct from the nation state (NS). This allows the specific characteristics of the largest non-Western nations to be unveiled; these are linked to their thousand-year history, traditional cultural codes (deeply rooted in both public and elite mindsets), and the resentment of universalism and of any attempts to impose an alien system of values upon them. It is inferred that Russia meets the civilization-state criteria in such a way that aligns it with the nation state category; within this frame of reference, certain states are shown to fall in between these two categories, as they can demonstrate only a limited range of prerequisites to qualify their inclusion on the civilization-state list. In this context, a number of states in the Arab World are referenced as examples. Two different interpretations of the notion of “civilizatianism” are revealed by examining this definition of the nature and political practices of the states. The authors, representing the interests of the mainstream political bodies of Asian civilizationstates, tend to use this notion in order to emphasize their spiritual and cultural supremacy in response to the exclusive claims to the global leadership, as well as to promote the idea of their “responsible” attitude to society governance and handling of global issues. However, their adversaries treat civilizationism as synonymous with authoritarianism, disrespecting the rights of minorities, archaic political practices, and national egoism. The author views the concept of the civilization-state not only as a weapon of ideological and political struggles, but also as a useful instrument for detecting the genuine peculiarities of such states, distinguishing them from the models based on the principles of neo-liberal democracy and universalism.

Keywords: civilization-state | China | guanxi | India | dharma | Eurasionism | civilizationism | identity | nation-state | Arab nationalism | religion |

Russian Science Citation Index


Gadzhiev Kamaludin
Национализм в роли идеологии / К.С. Гаджиев // Власть. – 2012. – № 11. – С. 4–8.

Volodin Andrey
Индия как «государство-цивилизация» // Общественные науки и современность. 2022. № 6. С. 106-124. DOI 10.31857/S0869049922060089.

Prokhorenko Irina
Nationalism, Separatism, Terrorism / Prokhorenko I.

Rashkovsky Evgeniy
«The modern sciences have been constantly enriched by a critical introspection that emerged and continues to emerge in the depth of christian spiritual experience...» / Rashkovsky E., Razdyakonov V.

Kondrat’ev Vladimir
Глобальное государство / В.Б. Кондратьев // Прямые инвестиции. – 2010. – № 3. – С. 66–68.

Frolov Alexander
Арабские ставки Пекина // Обозреватель-Observer. 2023. № 2. С. 25-35. DOI 10.48137/2074-2975_2023_2_25.

Naumkin Vitaly
Современный конвергентный арабский национализм в зеркале исторической памяти // Полис. Политические исследования. 2021. № 6. С. 42-59. DOI 10.17976/jpps/2021.06.04.

Gontmakher Evgeniy
Социальное государство и его перспективы [Текст] / Е.Ш. Гонтмахер // Отечественные записки. – 2014. – № 3. – С. 151 – 164.

Ivanov Stanislav
«Исламское государство» - угроза мировой безопасности [Текст] / С.М. Иванов // Зарубежное военное обозрение. – 2015. – № 12 (825). – С. 52 – 55.

Ivanov Stanislav
Проблемы и особенности борьбы с террористической группировкой "Исламское государство" [Текст] / С.М. Иванов // Зарубежное военное обозрение. – 2016. – № 6 (831). – С. 3 – 13.

Gadzhiev Kamaludin
Russian Federation: National State or a State of Nations?

Stepanova Ekaterina
«Исламское государство» как проблема безопасности России: характер и масштаб угрозы [Текст] / Е.А. Степанова // ПОНАРС Евразия. Аналитические записки. – 2015. – № 393. – С. 1 – 10.

Gemueva K.A., Salitskii Alexander, Shakhmatov A.
Индия и Китай в мировой экономике, энергетике и политике. М.: Ин-т стран Востока, 2015, 148 с.

El’yanov Anatoly ,
Государство: стратегии догоняющего развития. Ответственный редактор Эльянов А.Я., Солоницкий А.С., отв. секретарь Карлова Т.А., Умнов А.Ю. Сборник научных трудов, 10 а.л.

Lapkin Vladimir
Nation vs Empire in the Modern World Order

Gudimenko Dmitry
Национализм в современном мире: типологизация и формы проявления // Вопросы национальных и федеративных отношений. 2021. Т. 11, № 10 (79). С. 2710-2719. DOI 10.35775/PSI.2021.79.10.003.

Klinova Marina
State-Protector or Social State in Europe: at the Crossroads

Lunev Sergey
Impact of civilizational specifics of the biggest countries on their social, political and economic development: a comparative analysis [Text] е / S.I. Lunev, A.D. Voskressenski // Sravnitelnaya politika-Comparative politics. – 2016. – Vol. 7. – № 3(24). – P. 85 – 106.

Gontmakher Evgeniy , Zagladin N.
Государство на службе глобализации / Е.Ш. Гонтмахер, Н.В. Загладин // Россия в глобальной политике. – 2012. – Т. 10. – № 4. – С. 20–31.

Соболевская А.А.
Имперские традиции России и евразийство. /А.А. Соболевская, А.К. Попов // Философия хозяйства. – 2014. – № 3. – С. 109 – 124
Related publications

Comments (0)

No comments

Add comment

First news
Institute News

Natalia Romashkina made a report "The Problem of Strategic Stability in the Context of International Security and National Interests of Russia" at Section 4. "International Law, Peace, Security and National Interests of the Russian Federation" of the III All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference "Legal Support of National Security.



From April 17 to 19, 2024, the International Annual Scientific Conference "Lomonosov Readings" – "Human and Social Capital of Russia: New Challenges and Opportunities" is being held at the Faculty of Economics of Lomonosov Moscow State University.


Recently Published