Semenenko Irina, Lapkin Vladimir , Bardin Andrey, Pantin Vladimir
Between the State and the Nation: Dilemmas of Identity Policy in Post-Soviet Societies
Publication Type:


ISSN 1026-9487

DOI 10.17976/jpps/2017.05.05

Two closely related but essentially divergent political projects coexist on the post-Soviet states current political agenda: the formation of a modern civic nation and the consolidation of state institutions and national (nation-state) identity. The search for effective instruments to bridge the deep social and ethno-cultural cleavages their societies confront while promoting these projects brings identity issues to the forefront of political discourse. The article presents the results of a comparative analysis of identity politics strategies and practices pursued by political elites in three post-Soviet republics – Kazakhstan, Armenia and Belarus – cases that demonstrate a diversity of ethnic and cultural composition and of social and economic development resources. The research is based on in-depth interviews taken in research and expert institutions in these countries and is preceded by a critical overview of the concepts of the nation and nation-building in the post-Soviet context. The authors argue that there is a consistent divergence in the trajectories of the state and nation-building projects, and demonstrate that the potential of civic identity is often used to different ends in political and intellectual discourses. The political elites give a clear priority to the state-building agenda, while identity politics promoted by the state focus on the legitimization of the existing political regimes. An assessment of the prospects in post-Soviet societies for nation-building questions the universal appraisal of the “nation state” project in a transforming world order.  

Keywords: nation | nation-state | nation-building | nationalism | national identity | civic identity | identity politics | identity discourse | statehood | post-Soviet space | Kazakhstan | Armenia | Belarus |

Russian Science Citation Index



OTHER PUBLICATIONS ON THIS TOPIC

Semenenko Irina
Political Identity and Identity Politics / Semenenko Irina S.

Semenenko Irina, Lapkin Vladimir , Pantin Vladimir
Identity in the System of Coordinates of the World Development.

Gadzhiev Kamaludin
National Identity: Conceptual Aspect / GADZHIEV K.S.

Ryzhichkin Nikita
Постсоветский Казахстан. Пути формирования национальной идентичности // Свободная мысль. 2020. № 3 (1681). С. 175-186.

Semenenko Irina
Nationalism, Separatism, and Democracy. New Patterns of National Identity in “Old” Europe

Prokhorenko Irina
National identity in the conditions of regional integration: case of Spain

Prokhorenko Irina
Ethnopolitical conflict and politics of identity in Latin America

Gadzhiev Kamaludin
Russian Federation: National State or a State of Nations?

Vasiliev Victor
Austrian Identity and European Integration / Vasilyev V.I.

Lapkin Vladimir
Modernization, Globalization, Identity. General Problems and Russian Particularities.

Semenenko Irina
Prospects for identity research in the social sciences: promoting non-conflict public discussion (interview of professor Lyubov’ A. Fadeeva with corresponding member of RAS Irina S. Semenenko). Political science. 2020, N 4, P. 74–85. DOI: http://www.doi.org/10.31249/poln/2020.04.04


Russian nation-building problems in the context of international experience / Semenenko I.S.

Pantin Vladimir
National and civilization identity: Russian specificity / Pantin Vladimir I.


Metamorphoses of identity in the conditions of globalization. Summary / Lapkin Vladimir V.

Vainshtein Gregory
European Identity: the Desired and the Real.

Gadzhiev Kamaludin
Национализм в роли идеологии / К.С. Гаджиев // Власть. – 2012. – № 11. – С. 4–8.

Semenenko Irina
Dilemmas of National Identity: Political Risks and Social Inputs.
Related publications


Comments (0)

No comments

Add comment







First news
Institute News
10/07/2025

Attention readers of MEMO Journal! The following articles from issue 4 for 2025 are now freely available in English translation: V. Mikheev, S. Lukonin “China: Bitter Dish with Complex Garnish”; A. Romanova, E. Morozova “Sociocultural Aspects of the Integration of the Caspian Macroregion as a Potential 'Center of Power'”.

more...

08/07/2025

The next issue of the MEMO Journal (No. 7, 2025) is published. The leading place in it is occupied by articles on economic issues. 

more...

Recently Published