Between the State and the Nation: Dilemmas of Identity Policy in Post-Soviet Societies

Semenenko Irina, Lapkin Vladimir , Bardin Andrey, Pantin Vladimir
Between the State and the Nation: Dilemmas of Identity Policy in Post-Soviet Societies

Publication Type:
Articles in Journals

ISSN 1026-9487

DOI: 10.17976/jpps/2017.05.05

Two closely related but essentially divergent political projects coexist on the post-Soviet states current political agenda: the formation of a modern civic nation and the consolidation of state institutions and national (nation-state) identity. The search for effective instruments to bridge the deep social and ethno-cultural cleavages their societies confront while promoting these projects brings identity issues to the forefront of political discourse. The article presents the results of a comparative analysis of identity politics strategies and practices pursued by political elites in three post-Soviet republics – Kazakhstan, Armenia and Belarus – cases that demonstrate a diversity of ethnic and cultural composition and of social and economic development resources. The research is based on in-depth interviews taken in research and expert institutions in these countries and is preceded by a critical overview of the concepts of the nation and nation-building in the post-Soviet context. The authors argue that there is a consistent divergence in the trajectories of the state and nation-building projects, and demonstrate that the potential of civic identity is often used to different ends in political and intellectual discourses. The political elites give a clear priority to the state-building agenda, while identity politics promoted by the state focus on the legitimization of the existing political regimes. An assessment of the prospects in post-Soviet societies for nation-building questions the universal appraisal of the “nation state” project in a transforming world order.  

Keywords: nation | nation-state | nation-building | nationalism | national identity | civic identity | identity politics | identity discourse | statehood | post-Soviet space | Kazakhstan | Armenia | Belarus |

Russian Science Citation Index


Semenenko Irina
Political Identity and Identity Politics / Semenenko Irina S.

Semenenko Irina, Lapkin Vladimir , Pantin Vladimir
Identity in the System of Coordinates of the World Development.

Gadzhiev Kamaludin
National Identity: Conceptual Aspect / GADZHIEV K.S.

Semenenko Irina
Nationalism, Separatism, and Democracy. New Patterns of National Identity in “Old” Europe

Prokhorenko Irina
Ethnopolitical conflict and politics of identity in Latin America

Prokhorenko Irina
National identity in the conditions of regional integration: case of Spain

Vasil'ev Victor
Austrian Identity and European Integration / Vasilyev V.I.

Gadzhiev Kamaludin
Russian Federation: National State or a State of Nations?

Lapkin Vladimir
Modernization, Globalization, Identity. General Problems and Russian Particularities.

Russian nation-building problems in the context of international experience / Semenenko I.S.

Pantin Vladimir
National and civilization identity: Russian specificity / Pantin Vladimir I.

Metamorphoses of identity in the conditions of globalization. Summary / Lapkin Vladimir V.

Vainshtein Gregory
European Identity: the Desired and the Real.

Semenenko Irina
Dilemmas of National Identity: Political Risks and Social Inputs.

Gadzhiev Kamaludin
Национализм в роли идеологии / К.С. Гаджиев // Власть. – 2012. – № 11. – С. 4–8.

Gadzhiev Kamaludin
О кризисе национальной идентичности [Электронный ресурс] / К.С. Гаджиев // Мир и политика. – 2013. – № 1.

Solov’ev Eduard
Пятидневная война на Кавказе как фактор формирования российской внешнеполитической идентичности / Э.Г. Соловьёв // Мир и политика. – 2009. – № 37. – С. 52–62.
Еще публикации по теме

Comments (0)

No comments

Add comment

First news
Institute News

The final online session of the international forum "Primakov Readings – 2020" on the topic of "Russia and the post-COVID world" will be held within the framework of the joint project of IMEMO named after E.M. Primakov and Interfax news agency.



We bring to your attention the contents of the new issue of the journal «World Economy and International Relations» (2020, vol. 64, No. 7).


Recently Published