Timofeev Pavel, Khorolskaya Maria
Дилеммы европейской безопасности: сравнение подходов Германии и Франции к соотношению роли ЕС и НАТО в Европе после 2022 г. // Сравнительная политика. 2024. Т. 15, № 4. С. 132-154. DOI 10.46272/2221-3279-2024-4-15-8.
Publication Type:


ISSN 2221-3279

In 2016-2017, it was the Franco-German tandem which nurtured European security integration. The leaders of both states have been used to reaching a compromise despite different approaches to Atlanticism and Europeanism balance. However, the Ukrainian conflict escalation has changed the defense policies pursued by France and Germany. This paper argues, that during the last two years the differences between the two states concerning security issues have widened. With Germany even more relying on NATO as the most important security guarantor for Europe, France tends to simultaneously argue for a stronger, more independent European defense. Amid limited resources, it became more difficult for both parties to compromise. The article compares shifts in German and French policies on three levels, that are conceptual (the role of NATO and the EU in strategic papers and addresses of the French and German leaders), program-initiative (involvement in NATO and the EU security initiatives over the past two years), and military-industrial (joint projects and procurements). The research reveals that since the Ukrainian crisis escalation France and Germany have tended to rely on NATO as the main security guarantor, still the former is strongly committed to effectively strengthening European security. Germany and France differ in terms of their involvement in NATO and the EU security initiatives as well as procurements. Having its own nuclear weapons and military-industrial complex, the latter is less committed to NATO, yet highly supports European defense projects, seeking economic and political benefits. Germany prioritizes proven NATO structures, bilateral initiatives, as well as transatlantic defense procurements. The paper reveals a correlation between the policies of Germany and France and their dependence on the US military-industrial complex.


Keywords: France | Germany | Franco-German tandem | Ukrainian conflict | European strategic autonomy | NATO | military-industrial complex | arms procurement | European Sky Shield Initiative |

Russian Science Citation Index



OTHER PUBLICATIONS ON THIS TOPIC

Timofeev Pavel, Khorolskaya Maria
Approaches of the Franco-German tandem to interaction with Turkey in the hotbeds of instability in the Mediterranean

Timofeev Pavel, Khorolskaya Maria
Comparative Analysis of the Germany and France Approaches to Relations with Russia

Vasiliev Victor
Германия и Вышеградская «четверка»: один за всех и все за одного? // Международная жизнь. 2022. № 6. С. 106-115.

Arbatova Nadezhda
Relations of the European Union with the United States and NATO: dilemmas of euro-atlanticism. – Polis. Political Studies. 2024. No. 4. https://doi.org/10.17976/jpps/2024.04.08. EDN: JVFXKD (In Russ.)

Timofeev Pavel
Политика Франции на постсоветском пространстве [Текст] / П.П. Тимофеев // Современная Европа. – 2013. – № 2. – С. 86 – 100.

Vasiliev Victor
Крутые повороты в российско-германских отношениях // Обозреватель-Observer. 2021. № 1 (372). С. 5-27. DOI 10.48137/2074-2975_2021_1_5.

Malyshev Dmitry
Приднестровский конфликт и вопросы урегулирования // Международная жизнь. 2020. № 9. С. 58-71.

Oznobishchev S.
The New World and Russia NATO Relations.

Timofeev Pavel
FRANCE AND THE EU IN THE NEAR EAST / Timofeev P.P.

Sergeev Pavel
Ukrainian gas transit and the issues of gas supply in the European Union

Aleshin Alexander
Роль научного дискурса в стратегическом развитии НАТО // Международные процессы. 2022. № 4 (71). DOI 10.17994/IT.2022.20.4.71.1. URL: http://intertrends.ru/prevyu-statey/rol-nauchnogo-diskursa-v-strategicheskom-razvitii-nato. Опубликовано онлайн: 13.01.2023.

Sidorova Elena, Sidorov Aleksei
EU Strategic Autonomy in the Economy. International Trends / Mezhdunarodnye protsessy. 2023;21(3):119-142. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.17994/IT.2023.21.3.74.7

Shumitskaya Ekaterina
Германия и урегулирования приднестровского конфликта [Текст] / Е. В. Шумицкая // Анализ и прогноз. Журнал ИМЭМО РАН. – 2019. – № 2. – С. 48-60. DOI: 10.20542/afij-2019-2-48-60.

Khorolskaya Maria, Kramnik Ilya
Останется только один. Четыре танка и перспективы европейского производства // Россия в глобальной политике. 2023. Т. 21, № 6. С. 146-156. DOI 10.31278/1810-6439-2023-21-6-146-156.

Smirnov Alexey
Европейский правый центризм перед вызовом украинского конфликта: по ту сторону страха // Власть. 2023. Т. 31, № 5. С. 221-231. DOI 10.31171/vlast.v31i5.9821.

Gronsky Alexander
Украинский фактор в молдо-приднестровских отношениях // Аналитический бюллетень ИСПИРР. 2020. № 1-2 (3-4). С. 22-30.

Vasiliev Victor
Germany on the eve of the elections to the European Parliament / Vasilyev V.I.

Aleshin Alexander
The EU‒NATO Cooperation after the Start of the Special Military Operation

Gusarova Olga
Основные методы закупок в системе военной контрактации Великобритании // Московский экономический журнал : сетевое издание. 2021. № 11. С. 722-736. DOI 10.24412/2413-046Х-2021-10704. URL: https://qje.su/ekonomicheskaya-teoriya/moskovskij-ekonomicheskij-zhurnal-11-2021-62/ (дата обращения 27.12.2021).
Related publications


Comments (0)

No comments

Add comment







First news
Institute News
10/07/2025

The journal "Development Strategies" (No. 2 (19) 2025) published an interview with Alexander Krylov – "USA, Russia and the South Caucasus in the First Half of 2025".

more...

10/07/2025

Attention readers of MEMO Journal! The following articles from issue 4 for 2025 are now freely available in English translation: V. Mikheev, S. Lukonin “China: Bitter Dish with Complex Garnish”; A. Romanova, E. Morozova “Sociocultural Aspects of the Integration of the Caspian Macroregion as a Potential 'Center of Power'”.

more...

Recently Published