From Liberal World Order to Normalization of International Relations

DOI: 10.20542/0131-2227-2017-61-12-5-17

M. Entin (,
MGIMO University, 76, Vernadskogo Prosp., Moscow 119454, Russian Federation.
Immanuel Kant Baltic Federal University (IKBFU), 14, A. Nevskogo Str., Kaliningrad, 236041, Russian Federation;
E. Entina (,
National Research University High School of Economics, 20, Myasnitskaya Str., Moscow 101000, Russian Federation. Institute of Europe RAN, 11/3, Mokhovaya Str., Moscow, 125993, Russian Federation 


Nowadays, it has become very popular to say that the life span of liberal world order is over. The authors of the article do not share this view. They explain that liberal world order does not exist and never existed. It is not more than an ideological construct, which is tremendously beneficial to its designers and supporters, giving excuses and rationale for intervening, imposing and suppressing. It is proved by evidences taken from the present day functioning of world economy and world politics as well as from what is going on in the USA and the EU countries. What exists at the national, transnational and world level is a liberal cluster. It is in permanent competition with a lot of others. Lately, the liberal cluster was less successful than ever. Its inability to win the competition is exacerbated by the permanent crisis it tries to cope with. The challenge of populism, extreme right and left movements, low growth, etc. had a tremendous impact on it. To survive, it has started to change and evolve towards populist and nationalist liberalism. Political systems of the USA and a number of European countries have proved to be very flexible. They have absorbed the shock of change and new social and economic trends. But at the international level, such flexibility is lacking entirely. The inability of populist and nationalist liberal cluster to adapt to new reality generates international tensions, conflicts, uncertainty. This is a road to nowhere. If this reality is acknowledged it will pave the way for an entirely new understanding of transformational processes the USA and the EU countries are undergoing now. It will provide everybody with an opportunity to develop new approaches to international relations and common future. In such a way, international tensions could be eased, making international relations much more reliable, rational and comfortable. International community may succeed in transforming the world into an inclusive one and reshaping the world governance conforming to real needs of all countries and their population. 


liberal world order, world politics, world economy, evolution of political systems, USA, China, Russia, EU countries, normalization of international relations 


1. 20th Anniversary Annual International Conference in the Shlangenbad Conversations (Kranichstein, Germany, April 27–29, 2017) – “The Life Cycle of the Liberal Order: the Fall or Search for a New Norm” (In Russ.) Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

2. Speech and Q&A Session by the Russian Foreign Minister S. Lavrov at the 53rd Munich Security Conference, Munich, February 18, 2017 (In Russ.) Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

3. Brexit. Explore articles from 2007-Present. The Financial Times. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

4. Vologzhanin M. 27 koloritnykh faktov o Donal’de Trampe [27 Colorful Facts about Donald Trump]. Maxim Online. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

5. Luk’yanov F.A. Lovushki Trampa. Chto zhdat’ Rossii ot “novoi” Ameriki [Trump’s Traps. What to Wait for Russia from “New” America]. Russia in Global Affairs, November 17, 2016. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

6. Karaganov S.A. Trampu budut meshat’. Rossiya v global’noi politike [Trump will be disturbed]. Russia in Global Affairs, November 11, 2016. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

7. Kortunov A. Prezident D. Tramp I vyzovy amerikanskoy politiki [President D. Trump and Challenges of the American Policy]. RIAC, January 25, 2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

8. Gauquelin B. 60 ans du traite de Rome: Viktor Orban, le croise de l’Europe non liberale. Le premier ministre hongrois a consolide son pouvoir au mepris des valeurs europeennes. Le Monde, 22.03.2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

9. Adam B., Buras P., Gromadzki G., Smolar E. Polish Views of the EU: the Illusion of Consensus. Warsaw, Stefan Batory Foundation, 2017. 17 p. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

10. Rouban L. Pourquoi le populisme a gagne. Le grand vainqueur de cette election presidentielle est le… populisme! Les candidats s’en inspirant ont reuni la moitie de l’electorat au premier tour. Le Point, 25.04.2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

11. Rouban L. Cinq question sur le populisme. Le Point, 02.12.2016. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

12. La Presidentielle en temps reel. Paris Match, 05.05.2017 Available at: (accessed 18.05.2017).

13. La boite a sondages. BFMTV. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

14. Report “The European Union’s Uncertain Future: What should Russia do?” Moscow, Valdai International Discussion Club, 2017. 16 p. (In Russ.)

15. Entin M., Entina E. Russia and China Protecting the Contemporary World Order. Rivista di studi politici internazionali, (Firenze) 2016, no. 4, pp. 492-539.

16. Entin M.L. Kraeugol’nye osnovy poslevoennogo miroustroistva i sovremennogo mezhdunarodnogo prava: vzglyad iz Moskvy i Pekina [Cornerstones of a Post-War World Order and Modern International Law: View from Moscow and Beijing]. Moscow Journal of International Law, 2016, no. 3 (103), pp. 19-30.

17. Entin M.L. Mezhdunarodnoe pravo v epokhu peremen [International Law During the Era of Changes]. Sovremennoe mezhdunarodnoe pravo: globalizatsiya i integratsiya: LIBER AMICORUM v chest’ professora P.N. Biryukova: sbornik nauchnykh statei [Modern International Law: Globalization and Integration: LIBER AMICORUM in Honor of Professor P. Biryukov: Collection of Scientific Articles]. Voronezh, Izdatel’skii dom VGU, 2016, pp. 216-237.

18. Sieffert D. Poutine ou le revanchisme russe. Plusieurs ouvrages analysent la politique russe conduite depuis que l’ancien officier du KGB est devenu l’homme fort du Kremlin. Politis, L’hebdo, no. 1396, 2016. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

19. Sieffert D. Shine et la Russie: quelles strattegie? Fondation prospective et innovation. Ginkgo Editeur, 2015. 128 p.

20. De Saint Perier L. Enquete: comment Vladimir Poutine s’est rendu incontournable en Afrique du Nord et au Moyen-Orient. Jeune Afrique, 16.04.2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

21. Kochetov E.G. Geoekonomika. Osvoenie mirovogo ekonomicheskogo prostranstva: Uchebnik dlya vuzov [Geoeconomy. Development of World Economic Space: The Textbook for Higher Education Institutions]. Moscow, Norma, 2010. 528 p.

22. Kochetov E.G. Kosmologizatsiya. Novyi etap mirovogo razvitiya v kontekste gumanitarnoi kosmologii. Nauchnaya monografiya. [Cosmologization. A New Stage of World Development in the Context of Humanitarian Cosmology. Scientific Monography]. Moscow, Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2014. 912 p.

23. Kochetov E.G. Miry: Prolegomeny k filosofii preobrazheniya cheloveka i ego bytiya v mirakh gumanitarnogo kosmosa [Worlds: Prolegomena to Philosophy of Transformation of the Person and his Being in the Worlds of Humanitarian Cosm]. Moscow, Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2015. 560 p.

24. Grinin L.E Razmyshleniya o transformatsiyakh mirovogo poryadka. Chast’ 1. Mirovoi poryadok v proshlom i nastoyashchem [Reflections on Transformations of the World Order. Part 1. The World Order in the Past and Present]. Intelros, no. 1, 2017. Available at:–2017/32198-razmyshleniya-otransformaciyah-mirovogo-poryadka-chast-1-mirovoy-poryadok-v-proshlom-i-nastoyaschem.html (accessed 30.05.2017).

25. Grinin L., Korotayev A., Tausch A. Economic Cycles, Crises, and the Global Periphery. Springer International Publishing, 2016. XVIII. 265 p. DOI:10.1007/978-3-319-41262-7.

26. Kuvaldin V.B. Global’nyi mir. Politika. Ekonomika. Sotsial’nye otnosheniya [Global World. Policy. Economy. Social Relations]. Moscow, “Ves’ Mir”, 2017. 400 p.

27. 55/2. United Nations Millennium Declaration, September 8, 2000 (In Russ.) Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

28. 56/6. United Nations Global Agenda for Dialogue among Civilizations, November 9, 2001 (In Russ.) Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

29. 2005 World Summit Outcome, adopted by General Assembly Resolution, October 24, 2005 (In Russ.) Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

30. Future of World Religions: Demographic Growth Forecasts, 2010–2050. Why is the Share of Muslims in the World Population Grows with the Highest Rate, and the Proportion of non-religiously affiliated dwindles (In Russ.)], 08.02.2017] Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

31. Toohey L., Picker C.B., Greenacre J., eds. China in the International Economic Order. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2015. 344 p.

32. XVIII April International Academic Conference on Problems of Socio-Economic Development at the National Research University “Higher School of Economics”. Moscow, April 11–14, 2017 (In Russ.) Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

33. Entin M.L., Entina E.G., Tnelm N.I. V poiskakh partnerskikh otnoshenii – VI. Rossiya i Evropeiskii Soyuz v 2015–2016 godakh [In Search of Partnership – VI. Russia and the European Union in 2015–2016]. Moscow, Zebra-E, 2017. 816 p.

34. Entin M.L., Entina E.G., Tnelm N.I. V poiskakh partnerskikh otnoshenii – V. Rossiya i Evropeiskii Soyuz v 2011–2014 godakh [In search of Partnership – V. Russia and the European Union in 2011–2014]. Moscow, Eksmo, 2015, Vol. I, 864 p.; Vol. II, 1210 p.

35. Maksimov A.A. Bandity v belykh vorotnichkakh. Osobennosti natsional’noi privatizatsii. [Bandits in White Collars. Features of National Privatization]. Afery – Poddelki – Kriminal. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

36. Common Agricultural Policy. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

37. Russia has Submitted a laim to the WTO to Appeal an Anti-Dumping Measure of the EU Concerning Metallurgists., January 30, 2017 (In Russ.) Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

38. Medvedchuk V. Ukraina narashchivaet eksport v Rossiyu [Ukraine Increases Export to Russia]. Narodnyi korrespondent, 01.04.2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

39. Quaglia L. European Union Financial Regulations, Banking Union, Capital Markets Unions and the UK. Sheffield Political Economy Research Institute of the University of Sheffield and Foundation for European Progressive Studies, SPERI Paper, no. 38, 2017. 21 p. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

40. Donnan Sh. IMF Under Pressure in Washington over Greek Bailout. The Financial Times, 17.03.2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

41. Deutsche Bank Raises Capital, and Changes Course. A Troubled Bank Hopes to Turn the Page. The Economist, March 9, 2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

42. Mauldin J. Angst in America, Part 4: Disappearing Pensions. Mauldin Economics, April 16, 2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

43. Entin M.L., Entina E.G. Vozvrashchenie ery konservativnogo natsionalizma v ES i SShA [Return of the Era of Conservative Nationalism in the EU and USA]. Vsya, no. 3 (119), 2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

44. L’invasion migratoire est pour l’Europe un “defi existentiel”. Blanche Europe, 20 mars 2016. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

45. Sardou M. s’inquiete de “l’invasion passive” des refugies. LCI, 12 septembre 2016. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

46. Le pape denonce les “camps de concentration” pour refugies. Le Point, 23.04.2017. Available at:‑22-04-2017-2121780_23.php (accessed 30.05.2017).

47. Neumann I.B., ed. Regional Great Powers in International Politics. Basingstoke, St. Martin’s Press, 1992. 210 p. DOI:10.1007/907-1-349-12661-3.

48. McInnes C., ed. Security and Strategy in the New Europe. London, New York, Routledge, 2002. 272 p.

49. Kauffmann S. Sees publications. Le Monde. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

50. Lukin A.V., Korotich S.A. Mezhdu Vashingtonom i Pekinom: chto zhdet aziatsko-tikhookeanskie al’yansy SShA? [Between Washington and Beijing: What Awaits the Asia-Pacific Alliances of the USA?] Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2017, vol. 61, no. 4, pp. 5-15. DOI:10.20542/0131-2227-2017-61-4-5-15.

51. Sheinis V.L. Politicheskie sistemy Evropeiskogo soyuza pered novymi vyzovami [Political Systems of the European Union in Front of New Challenges]. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2017, vol. 61, no. 2, pp. 23-32. DOI:10.20542/0131-2227-2017-61-2-23-32.

52. Kauffmann S. L’effet papillon de l’election d’Emmanuel Macron. Le Monde, 13.05.2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

53. Perspectives de l’economie mondiale. Fonds monetaire international, Etudes economiques et financieres, April, 2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

54. Perspectives de l’economie mondiale: un nouvel elan? Fonds monetaire international, Etudes economiques et financieres, Avril, 2017. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

55. Karaganov S.A. Perelomnyi god: predvaritel’nye itogi. Shans dlya kardinal’nogo obnovleniya. [Critical Year: Preliminary Results. Chance for a Cardinal Update]. Russia in Global Affairs, 17.12.2014. Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017).

56. S. Karaganov Named an Unexpected Condition of Cancellation of Sanctions Against Russia. The Political Analyst has Presented his Vision of the Global Situation. MK.RU, 16.01. 2016. (In Russ.) Available at: (accessed 30.05.2017). 

Registered in system SCIENCE INDEX

For citation:
Entin M., Entina E. From Liberal World Order to Normalization of International Relations. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2017, vol. 61, No 12, pp. 5-17.

Comments (0)

No comments

Add comment

Current Issue
2020, vol. 64, No. 7
Topical Themes of the Issue:

  • Drivers of Global Economy
  • D. Trump’s Economic Model: Results and Prospects
  • European Union: Second Generation Trade Agreements
  • USA–Iran: between “Maximum Pressure” and “Heroic Flexibility”
  • Protest Potential of the Latin America: Regional Aspect of Global Phenomenon
View This Issue (2020, vol. 64, No. 7)
Submit an Article

Dear readers!
Please note that free access to full-text issues of the Journal is being opened at our WEB-site after 6 months of the date of publications. Currently, the releases of 2015–2018 are available for free. The work on deepening the open archive of full-text issues will be continued.

Dear readers!
This is to inform the researchers of the Institute of World Economy and International Relations that electronic version of the 4-nd issue of 2019 of French magazine Politique étrangère is now available. Those who are interested, please personally address to the editorial staff of MEMO Journal (room 18-17) with an electronic media (e-mailing is not possible because of technical reasons).


In response to the challenges of our time the Editorial board continues to open new thematic rubrics:

“The Common Spaces”. The XX century was marked by the process of active development of the so-called common spaces, namely the World ocean, outer space and the Internet which, due to various reasons, were previously perceived as peripheral for the mankind and were not used at all or less intensively. Since then, the degree of their development and usage is constantly increasing. Even though the prospects of obtaining material dividends from their use are often extremely remote, the level of competition there is steadily increasing, resulting in growing inter-state conflicts’ potential.

“Silk Road and prospects of Great Eurasia”. It is planned to publish materials concerning the Chinese project of Silk Road and its impact on the socio-economic development of various countries in Eurasia and the integration processes in this mega-region.

“Africa today and tomorrow”The rubric devoted to contemporary issues of Africa which is attracting growing interest of the world's leading actors. We plan to publish the articles analyzing the status of statehood, socio-economic and political development of the countries of Black continent, as well as the integration processes between them.

“Civilization processes of modern development” is a new rubric opened by MEMO Journal in 2020. It will be devoted to the analysis of the influence of civilizational factors and inter-civilizational interactions on the political and socio-economic development of the world at whole, regions and countries.

Dear colleagues, authors and readers!

We kindly request you to turn to editor-in-chief and executive secretary directly concerning reviewing scientific publications in our journal. Only editor-in-chief takes decision on order and publication the reviews!


"World Eonomy and International Relations" announces a contest for the best joint academic publications of domestic and foreign researchers and experts in topical issues of the world economy and international relations. The winners will be selected according to the results of peer reviewing and discussion at the Editorial Board. The articles will be published in priority order.


The print version of “World Economy and International Relations” journal is distributed by advance subscription only, and is not offered for retail sale. To subscribe please address to any post office in Russia by referring to the Federal Postal Service Union Catalogue, section “ARSMI”, the journal index is 70542. The subscription may be made for the whole subscription period or starting from any nearest available month for desired number of issues.

To purchase the full-text electronic version of the journal’s issue/article please address to the WEB portal of Scientific electronic library or URL:

In journal
                     Articles by year
                     Authors by year
2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000 | 1999 | 1998 | 1997 |

The author’s opinions may not coincide with the position of editorial