Budget Decentralisation in Federal and Unitary States: An Analysis of the OECD Statistics

Gracheva Mariya
Budget Decentralisation in Federal and Unitary States: An Analysis of the OECD Statistics

Publication Type:
Articles in Journals
The article considers the peculiarities of intergovernmental fiscal relations between the central budget level and the subcentral (regional / local or local only) budget levels in federative and unitary states on the basis of the Organisation of Economic Cooperation and Development’s statistics (OECD statistics). The author analysed several quantitative indicators characterizing the subcentral budget levels’ positions in the following lines: tax autonomy, intergovernmental grants, revenue and spending of the consolidated budget, tax revenue and intergovernmental transfer revenue, budget balance and budget debt, fiscal rules and financial stability. Some significant differences were identified between the groups of federative and unitary states; also in several cases some serious deviations from the intragroup average values were discovered. According to the author’s own calculations, the OECD countries were allocated into four categories based on the value of the integral indicator characterizing the role of subcentral budget levels. It helped to conclude that there is quite a close link between the federative / unitary type of the state and the degree of budget decentralisation and at the same time the decentralized systems of intergovernmental fiscal relations can be found not only in the federative, but also in the unitary states. 

Keywords: budget decentralisation | intergovernmental fiscal relations | budget levels | role of subcentral budget levels | federative states | unitary states |


Smyslov Dmitry
Внешнее финансирование России в переходный период. М., ИМЭМО РАН, 2001, 16 п.л.

Bogachyova Olga, Lavrov A.M., Yastrebova O.K.
Международный опыт программного бюджетирования / О.В. Богачева, А.М. Лавров, О.К. Ястребова // Финансы. – 2010. – № 12. – С. 4–14.

Bogachyova Olga, Sidorenko V, Yastrebova O
Adoption of Program Budgeting: Issues and Solutions / Bogacheva Olga V., Sidorenko Valery V., Yastrebova Olga K.

Toganova Natalia
The Future of Welfare State in Germany

Gracheva Mariya
Динамика и структура расходов федерального бюджета Германии [Текст] / М.В. Грачева // Финансы. – 2013. – № 5. – С. 69 – 74.

Klinova Marina
State and Business Interaction: Survey of Economics and Policy Through Time // Economic Strategies. – 2016. - N 4 (138). – P. 186-197.

Sidorova Elena
The crisis and its consequences for the economies of Germany, Great Britain and Russia // Economy of the XXI century. - 2010. - № 5. - S. 107-122.

Klinova Marina
A View in the Retrospect of Time: A History of State and Business Interaction. Russian and Soviet Marxism on the State’s Role in the Economy // Economic Strategies. – 2017. – No 5 (147). – P. 200–213.

Prokhorenko Irina
Autonomous Communities of Spain in the Political Space of the European Union / Prohorenko I.L.

Sidorova Elena
Fiscal Policy in the EU. Manual. Moscow: MGIMO-University, 2014, 282 p.

Sidorova Elena
European Union: Common budget after Lisbon // Contemporary Europe. 2011. No 4. P. 109-123.

Klinova Marina
From the History of State and Business Interaction. Mercantilism and its Varieties in Western Europe and in Russia / Marina Klinova // Economic Strategies. - 2016. - N 2(136). - P. 132-139.

Klinova Marina
The Role of the State in the European Union Economy // Herald of the Russian Academy of sciences. 2015. Vol. 85, no 12. P. 1113-1122

Gilkova Olga
Сущность, роль и значение финансов в экономическом обеспечении военных приготовлений современного государства [Текст] / О.Н. Гилькова // Горизонты экономики. – 2017. – № 4. – С. 7-11.

Klinova Marina
Globalization and Infrastructure: New Trends in the State and Business Cooperation / M. Klinova // Voprosy Economiki . – 2008. – № 8. – P. 78-90.

Klinova Marina
The State and Private Capital: from Theory to Practice of Interaction in European Countries. Moscow, Magistr, 2011, 400 p.

Rastol'tsev Sergey
Три мифа о «замороженных» конфликтах на постсоветском пространстве в Европе: критический анализ [Текст] / С. В. Растольцев // Международные отношения. – 2018. – № 4. – С. 82-94. DOI: 10.7256/2454-0641.2018.4.28227.

Bahtaraeva Karina
Italy’s investment and tax policy under the state credit control during the period of economic modernization

Sidorova Elena
Elena Sidorova. Fiscal Integration in the EU after the Great Recession. Chapter in the monograph, pp. 205–212. International Economic Relations: Realities, Challenges and Prospects. (in Russian) / L.S. Revenko (ed.). – Moscow, MGIMO-University, 2019. – 750 p.

Rogozhina Natalia
The Role of the State in the Environmental Modernization of Southeast Asian Countries. Moscow, IMEMO RAN, 2004.
Еще публикации по теме

Comments (0)

No comments

Add comment

First news
Institute News

February 15, 2019, Gelber Salon, Bayerischer Hof Hotel, Munich. IMEMO/Primakov Readings Roundtable at MSC 2020 "Russian Foreign Policy Choices in the New Era of Great Power Competition".



The roundtable conference «THE FUTURE OF THINK TANKS AND POLICY ADVICE», dedicated to the presentation of the annual international ranking of the think tanks «Global Go To Think Tank Index Report 2019», was held at the IMEMO.


Recently Published